"Shitty First Drafts" Reading Response
“Shitty First Drafts”, a passage from Anne Lamott’s Bird by Bird, explores the importance of
jumbled and chaotic first drafts to achieve concise writing with flow and
purpose. The idea that every writer has overflowing ideas and the ability to
put those ideas into quality writing is a very common misconception. Lamott
stresses the idea of writing bad first drafts that can be later molded, cut,
and altered into something amazing. The statement about having to step away
from the computer to breathe and clear your mind stuck out to me because that
is personally what I do, or else I feel like I can’t put anything I am thinking
into words. Lamott’s anecdote about being a food review author made it easy for
to empathize with her in that situation. If I had a paper for school, I would
sit down thinking that I must write something with quality or I would not be
able to meet the deadline, write a good paper, etc. It is hard for me to grasp
the concept of writing so much extra, “shitty” content that will just later be
deleted or overlooked. I already understand the importance of multiple drafts
to develop a cohesive and well written piece, but I like every draft to have a
purpose and some sort of rhyme or reason or else I just feel like I’m writing
for nothing. I think Lamott’s fear of someone finding her first draft is silly
because she says that one of the purposes of a first draft is for it to be bad.
I also find it ironic how her whole article is clearly summarized and the
purpose can be understood in the last paragraph when the rest of the article is
anecdotes and fluff to prove her point. Overall the article was interesting and
had decent points, but the message isn’t something I haven’t heard or seen
before.
Hi Emily
ReplyDeleteThank you for your perspective and reflecting upon the text. Lamott proposes the first draft as a "spill out" moment when the writer just pours all their thoughts without minding structure or form. That would be the goal of the first draft. However, you don't have to abide by it. If your writing process works for you and it's enjoyable, go for it, but if you want to try something new, I encourage attempting the shitty first draft approach